Best Online Sportsbooks in NY

New Yorkers love their sports. From the roar of Yankee Stadium to the electric atmosphere at Madison Square Garden, the Empire State lives and breathes competition. And since online sports betting became legal in 2022, that passion has spilled over into the digital world. Whether you’re a die-hard Knicks fan, a Bills supporter dreaming of a Super Bowl, or just someone looking to add a little thrill to game day, finding the best online sportsbooks in NY is key to elevating your experience.

But with so many options—nine licensed sportsbooks as of March 2025—how do you choose the right one? Don’t worry; I’ve got you covered. In this guide, we’ll dive into the top NY sportsbooks, breaking down what makes them stand out, how they cater to different types of bettors, and what you need to know to get started. Plus, I’ll sprinkle in some real-world insights to help you feel confident placing your first wager. Let’s jump in!

Why Online Sports Betting in New York is Booming

Before we get into the nitty-gritty of the best online sportsbooks, let’s talk about why sports betting has taken off in New York. It’s no surprise, really. The state has a rich sports history—think horse racing at Saratoga or the Yankees’ 27 World Series titles. When the U.S. Supreme Court struck down PASPA in 2018, opening the door for legal sports betting, New York didn’t waste time. By April 2021, mobile sports betting was greenlit, and the first online sportsbooks launched in January 2022.

Since then, the numbers have been staggering. In its first eight months, New York racked up over $10.6 billion in betting handle (that’s the total amount wagered). Fast forward to 2025, and the market is still growing, fueled by passionate fans and a lineup of top-tier sportsbooks. Whether you’re betting on the NFL, NBA, MLB, or even niche sports like tennis or MMA, there’s something for everyone.

But here’s the thing: not all sportsbooks are created equal. Some offer killer welcome bonuses, while others shine with live betting or competitive odds. Let’s explore the best online sportsbooks in NY so you can find the perfect fit.

Top 9 Online Sportsbooks in New York for 2025

New York’s sports betting law caps the number of licensed operators at nine, and as of March 23, 2025, all nine slots are filled. These platforms have been vetted by the New York State Gaming Commission, ensuring they’re safe, legal, and ready for action. Here’s a rundown of the best online sportsbooks in NY, complete with what makes them special.

FanDuel Sportsbook

If you’ve ever placed a bet online, you’ve probably heard of FanDuel. It’s a juggernaut in the sports betting world, and for good reason. FanDuel was one of the first sportsbooks to go live in New York in 2022, and it’s held its spot as a top choice ever since.

• Why It’s Great: FanDuel is the king of user experience. The app is sleek, fast, and intuitive—perfect for betting on the go. Plus, they pioneered the Same Game Parlay, letting you combine multiple bets from one game for bigger payouts.
• Welcome Bonus: New users can place a $5 wager and get $200 in bonus bets if it wins. It’s a low-risk way to dip your toes in.
• Best For: Casual bettors and parlay lovers. If you enjoy crafting creative bets, FanDuel’s your spot.
• Standout Feature: Live streaming. You can watch select games right in the app while you bet.

I’ve used FanDuel during playoff season, and the real-time odds updates kept me on the edge of my seat. It’s like having a sports bar in your pocket.

DraftKings Sportsbook

DraftKings is FanDuel’s biggest rival, and in New York, they’ve teamed up to dominate the market. If you’re looking for variety, DraftKings delivers.

• Why It’s Great: With a massive range of sports—think NFL, NBA, soccer, even esports—DraftKings caters to every type of bettor. Their odds are consistently competitive, too.
• Welcome Bonus: Bet $5 and get $150 in bonus bets, win or lose. It’s a solid deal for newcomers.
• Best For: Serious bettors who want depth and flexibility.
• Standout Feature: Daily fantasy sports integration. You can switch between betting and fantasy seamlessly.

A friend of mine swears by DraftKings for NBA betting. He loves how easy it is to find player props, like betting on Jalen Brunson’s points total.

BetMGM

BetMGM, backed by MGM Resorts, brings a touch of Vegas flair to New York. It’s a powerhouse with a reputation for generous promos.

• Why It’s Great: BetMGM offers one of the most extensive betting menus out there—30+ sports, including niche options like table tennis. Their live betting is top-notch, too.
• Welcome Bonus: No standard offer, but their “Refer a Friend” deal gets you $100 per referral (up to $2,000). Plus, the BetMGM Rewards program adds perks over time.
• Best For: Bonus hunters and live betting fans.
• Standout Feature: Odds boosts. You’ll find daily specials that juice up your potential winnings.

I once scored a sweet odds boost on a Mets game with BetMGM. It turned a small bet into a nice payout—definitely worth keeping an eye on.

Caesars Sportsbook

Caesars made a splash in New York after acquiring William Hill, and it’s been a fan favorite ever since. It’s all about premium vibes here.

• Why It’s Great: Caesars offers a polished app and a ton of odds boosts across sports like MLB and NFL. Their customer service is also a cut above.
• Welcome Bonus: Bet $10 and get up to $1,000 back in bet credits if it loses (use promo code BOOKIES1000). It’s one of the biggest offers in NY.
• Best For: Bettors who want a high-end feel and big promos.
• Standout Feature: Rewards tied to Caesars’ retail properties. Bet online, earn points, and redeem them at places like Caesars Palace.

My cousin used Caesars during football season and raved about the profit boosts. He turned a $25 bet into $75 with one click.

BetRivers

BetRivers might not have the name recognition of FanDuel or DraftKings, but it’s a hidden gem for NY bettors.

• Why It’s Great: Low playthrough requirements on bonuses (just 1x) make it easy to cash out winnings. They also cover a wide range of sports.
• Welcome Bonus: A 100% match up to $500 with a 1x rollover—super straightforward.
• Best For: Budget bettors who want quick access to bonus cash.
• Standout Feature: Local ties. BetRivers runs a retail sportsbook at Rivers Casino Schenectady, giving it a NY flavor.

I’ve heard BetRivers is great for smaller bets. A coworker used it for hockey season and loved how fast he could withdraw.

Fanatics Sportsbook

Fanatics is better known for jerseys and gear, but their sportsbook is making waves in New York.

• Why It’s Great: You can earn FanCash (redeemable for merchandise) while betting. It’s a unique twist that ties betting to fandom.
• Welcome Bonus: Up to $1,000 in bonus bets—get $100 back daily for 10 days if your bet loses.
• Best For: Sports fans who love swag.
• Standout Feature: Integrated rewards. Your bets can score you a new Knicks jersey.

I haven’t tried Fanatics yet, but the idea of turning losses into a free hat sounds pretty cool.

Bet365

Bet365 is a global giant that’s carved out a strong niche in New York.

• Why It’s Great: Known for some of the best odds in the biz, especially on soccer and NFL. Their early cash-out feature is a lifesaver, too.
• Welcome Bonus: Bet $5, get $150 in bonus bets.
• Best For: Savvy bettors who shop for the best lines.
• Standout Feature: Extensive live betting options.

A buddy of mine uses Bet365 for soccer bets and swears it’s the best for international leagues.

Bally Bet

Bally Bet keeps things straightforward, which is perfect if you’re new to betting.

• Why It’s Great: Clean interface and solid coverage of major sports like MLB and NBA.
• Welcome Bonus: Varies, but expect a modest deposit match or risk-free bet.
• Best For: Beginners who want no fuss.
• Standout Feature: Ties to Bally’s casino brand.

It’s not flashy, but it gets the job done—great for a quick Yankees bet.

Resorts World Bet

Rounding out the list, Resorts World Bet brings a New York-centric vibe.

• Why It’s Great: Linked to Resorts World casinos in Queens and the Catskills, it’s got a homegrown feel. Decent odds and promos, too.
• Welcome Bonus: Typically a small risk-free bet or deposit match.
• Best For: NY locals who like supporting regional brands.
• Standout Feature: Retail betting integration.

It’s a solid pick if you’re near one of their physical locations.

How to Choose the Best NY Sportsbook for You

With nine great options, picking the best online sportsbook in NY comes down to your priorities. Here’s a quick guide to help you decide:

• If You Want Bonuses: Go for Caesars or BetMGM. Their offers are generous and ongoing.
• If You Love Live Betting: BetMGM and Bet365 lead the pack with real-time options.
• If You’re a Beginner: FanDuel or Bally Bet—easy to use and welcoming.
• If You Want Rewards: Fanatics or Caesars tie betting to tangible perks.
• If Odds Matter Most: Bet365 or DraftKings usually edge out the competition.

Think about what you value—convenience, payouts, or maybe just a fun vibe—and match it to the list above.

Getting Started: How to Bet Online in New York

Ready to jump in? Here’s how to start betting with the best online sportsbooks in NY:

1. Pick a Sportsbook: Use this guide to choose one that fits your style.
2. Sign Up: Download the app or visit the site, then enter your info (name, address, last four digits of your SSN) to verify you’re 21+ and in NY.
3. Deposit Funds: Most sportsbooks accept credit cards, PayPal, or bank transfers. Start with $10–$20 to test the waters.
4. Claim Your Bonus: Enter any promo codes during signup or your first deposit.
5. Place a Bet: Browse the markets—moneyline, spreads, props—and tap to add to your bet slip. Confirm, and you’re in!

Pro tip: Always check the geolocation feature is on. NY sportsbooks use it to ensure you’re within state lines.

What Makes a Great NY Sportsbook?

Not sure what to look for? Here are the key ingredients of the best online sportsbooks in NY:

• Competitive Odds: The difference between -110 and -105 might seem small, but it adds up.
• Variety of Markets: From NFL point spreads to UFC round betting, more options mean more fun.
• Fast Payouts: Nothing’s worse than waiting days for your winnings.
• User-Friendly App: A clunky interface kills the vibe.
• Promos: Welcome bonuses, odds boosts, and loyalty rewards keep things exciting.

Tips for Betting Smart in New York

Betting’s a blast, but it’s even better when you win. Here are some tips from my own trial-and-error:

• Start Small: Test the waters with $5 or $10 bets before going big.
• Shop Around: Compare odds across sportsbooks. A few cents can mean a bigger payout.
• Use Bonuses Wisely: Read the terms—some bonuses have playthrough rules.
• Keep a Log: Track your bets to spot patterns and refine your strategy.
• Stay Disciplined: Set a budget and stick to it. It’s a marathon, not a sprint.

The Future of Online Sports Betting in NY

As of March 2025, New York’s sports betting scene is thriving, but there’s still room to grow. Talks about legalizing online casinos are heating up, and if that happens, sportsbooks might add more gaming options. For now, the focus is on enhancing mobile apps, offering better promos, and keeping fans engaged year-round.

Final Thoughts

The best online sportsbooks in NY cater to every type of bettor—whether you’re chasing big bonuses with Caesars, crafting parlays on FanDuel, or scoring FanCash with Fanatics. Each one brings something unique to the table, and with a little exploration, you’ll find your perfect match.

So, what’s your next move? Download an app, claim a bonus, and get in on the action. The Bills might finally win the Super Bowl this year—or at least cover the spread. Either way, with these top NY sportsbooks, you’re set for a winning experience. Happy betting!